Don’t believe the hype

An exploration of some of the hyped (over-hyped?) technologies

Hype can be defined as a marketing technique that exaggerates the capabilities of a product, service, or technology to stimulate consumer demand artificially. Often involving bold claims, emotional appeals, and widespread publicity, it can be very effective. However, if expectations don’t meet the real-world experience of consumers, then the credibility of the brand/concept can be damaged.

Here, some recent examples of technologies (brands) that have been hyped – some fairly so, others not.

Blockchain

Further to the hype surrounding cryptocurrencies, the underlying blockchain technology was heralded as a “game-changer” – set to introduce new standards of transparency, security, and efficiency. Blockchain promised to disrupt finance, healthcare, supply chain, and even voting systems. From decentralised ledgers to smart contracts, blockchain was marketed as a secure and transparent way to conduct transactions without intermediaries.

At its peak, virtually every industry sector and government were considering using blockchain in some way – it was the “buzz” technology of the day.

Whilst great in theory, blockchain, as a solution to everything, soon floundered when faced with real-world realities. The technology was hard to scale, was very network dependent, had high energy use and created regulatory uncertainties. The resultant failed projects, businesses and investments have since consigned blockchain to niche markets, and in the process cementing blockchain as one of the most over-hyped technologies. 

Augmented Reality / Virtual Reality

Similar in many ways, dissimilar in some, these two related technologies were both hyped as being transformative to the way people would work, interact and play with the real world.

Both technologies were founded in research from the 1960’s, with increased awareness driven through the 80’s and 90’s (in large part by popular culture with films like Tron, Terminator, The Matrix, Avatar etc.) reaching peak hype in the latter part of the 2010’s with the launch of Oculus Rift (2012), the short-lived Google Glass (2013) and the purchase of Oculus by Facebook (2014). Facebook renamed itself as Meta in 2021 to focus on the “metaverse”.

Reality, though, failed to match the hype. Both AR and VR initially suffered from severe technical challenges with hardware unable to deliver a compelling experience, and whilst this has been somewhat overcome with the latest generation of devices, high hardware costs are a continuing barrier to widespread adoption, as are privacy issues surrounding AR apps.

With the absence of a “killer app” for either technology that would make it indispensable for everyday users, AR and VR are becoming high-end niche technologies. Whilst these technologies have matured, they have comprehensively failed to live up to their initial hype.

5G

Launched in the UK in 2019 amidst much fanfare by network providers and mobile phone manufacturers, 5G promised to deliver faster speeds (up to 100x more than 4G), lower latency, increased capacity and enhanced reliability. These enhancements would in turn revolutionise society – allowing for the development and adoption of high-bandwidth services, from entertainment, VR and AR, “smart cities”, the Internet of Things, autonomous cars and “mission-critical” applications to name but a few.

However, reality hasn’t lived up to the early hype. For those who did invest in new 5G compatible devices, download speeds have generally only been incremental over 4G, coverage has been patchy due to the slow buildout of the 5G network and reliability hasn’t been as high as expected. 

With no “killer app” for the mass market, and no significant benefit of 5G over 4G for the majority of consumer use cases, consumer demand for 5G has been less than expected.

These downsides are improving as investment is made in the provider’s networks. However, they may not be complete until the next wireless standard, 6G, is due to be launched in 2030. Which promises, interestingly, to deliver the same things that 5G should have.

3D

 
The hype surrounding 3D was one of the most intense and short-lived tech phenomena in recent history.

Originally developed during the 1950’s for cinema, the technology was revitalised during the 80’s and 90’s by new cinematic formats such as IMAX and was popularised by James Cameron’s 3D version of Avatar in 2009.

Introduced in the late 2000s, 3D TVs were marketed as the next major evolution in home entertainment. Manufacturers, media companies, and retailers all played a part in building excitement around the technology, promising immersive experiences that would change the way people watched movies, TV shows, and sports.

The hype, as expected, didn’t live up to reality. 

  • Consumers didn’t like having to wear special glasses to experience 3D content (a lesson that AR & VR protagonists failed to learn from)
  • 3D content was very limited (with much of it being sub-standard reprocessed 2D content) 
  • There was a substantial cost barrier to entry, with 3D-enabled devices marketed at the premium end of the market.

By 2013, the 3D market had begun to stagnate with manufacturers and content providers focusing instead on higher resolution content (4K UHD and HDR, for example), and by 2017, all the major manufacturers had left the market.

AI

If the media is proven right, we’re already in the midst of an AI-driven revolution. But is this hype or reality?

Make no mistake, AI is delivering transformational change. However, this article isn’t discussing whether a technology is good or not, but how a technology compares to what it has been hyped to deliver.

In simplistic terms, if you believe the hype, AI has promised to deliver virtually everything you could wish for. Indeed, there are currently thousands of startups focusing on bringing the “benefits of AI” to a wider and wider market backed by huge amounts of investor funding – the vast majority of these will fail.

AI will be a success. As it matures, it will revolutionise many sectors and deliver significant value. Will AI deliver all that it has been hyped to deliver – no.

Honourable mentions – Quantum Computing & Fusion

Despite being very much in their infancy, quantum computing and fusion power have both been subject to significant hype over the years. Both have been presented as transformative technologies that could revolutionise industry and society. 

While there is genuine potential behind both, the hype has often outpaced current realities, leading to inflated expectations.
Quantum computing promises to solve complex problems that are beyond the reach of classical computers – potentially opening a new age of scientific discovery, whilst breaking all forms of current cryptography. Whilst fusion power, which has been around the corner for the last forty years, promises to solve mankind’s energy needs.

Whilst both technologies have been proven, in theory and practice, their real-world deployment remains undefined, with many technical and physical obstacles yet to be overcome.

Transformative technologies – yes, but when, if ever?

In summary

Hype plays a significant role in marketing by creating excitement, anticipation, and buzz around a product, service, or event. When used effectively, hype can lead to increased consumer interest, media attention, and higher sales.

While hype can create a positive buzz, it also sets high expectations. If the product or service doesn’t live up to the anticipation, it can lead to disappointment and backlash. This downside highlights the importance of delivering on the promises made during a hype-driven marketing campaign.

About Hot Lemon

Hot Lemon provides marketing consultancy, website development and branding support for businesses across Tunbridge Wells, Kent, London and the South East.